You need 5-a-day fruit, veg? No you don’t! – Dr Zoë Harcombe

fruit.veg

5-A-DAY fruit and veg servings – it’s a mantra that doctors and dietitians repeat as if it’s written in stone.

They even say you can drink most of those servings, and that fruit and veg juices are instant boosts for your health.

Yet 5-a-day has no science behind it whatsoever, says British obesity researcher Dr Zoë Harcombe. Someone  plucked the number out of thin air. It’s a memorable number, she says, the same as the digits on one hand. Presumably, whoever made it up thinks that makes it easier for people to count servings?) The campaign is a different number-a-day across more than 25 countries, she says. Some say three, others four, five or more.  

Harcombe is not saying you shouldn’t eat fruit and veg. Just don’t believe the magical health benefits doctors and dietitians promise you because there isn’t any science to show there will be. During my last visit to London, the British government told its citizens that fruit juice should no longer be part of 5-a-day servings – because of the high sugar content. Harcombe says she’ll only drink a toast to that advice when …

the experts have ditched 5-a-day advice altogether.

In an earlier post on Foodmed.net she busts all the myths about diet and nutrition including 5-a-day. Watch this video below to see why Harcombe says 5-a-day is such an enduring myth and who is most like to benefit from it. Spoiler alert: it’s not you!  – Marika Sboros